The Booker shortlist was announced on monday september 16th, and we have about a month to read through the 6 books before it is revelaed to us on tuesday november 12th who the winner is of the 2024 Booker prize.
For the die hards, the booker longlist was released on July 30th, so the superfans had probably read them all before the shortlist was even announced. So to be thorough, the longlist comprised of 13 books:
- Headshot by Rita Bullwinkel
- The safekeep by Yael Van Der Wouden
- James by Percival Everett
- Wild houses by Colin Barrett
- My friends by Hisham Matar
- Stone Yard Devotional by Charlotte Wood
- Held by Anne Michaels
- Orbital by Samantha Harvey
- Creation Lake by Rachel Kushner
- Enlightenment by Sarah Perry
- The Strange Eventful history by Claire Messud
- Wandering stars by Tommy Orange
- Playground by Richard Powers

Before the list was released I had already read James by Percival Everett and I had added Wandering stars by Tommy Orange and Playground by Richard Powers to my reading list. I was surprised I had already tagged books on this list, as that is a rare event for me. The booker and I haven’t usually gotten along that great in the past. As the longlist came out I started reading Headshot by Rita Bullwinkel because I also found that book on Obama’s reading list for the summer.
When the shortlist dropped 6 books had made it:
- The safekeep by Yael Van Der Wouden
- James by Percival Everett
- Stone Yard Devotional by Charlotte Wood
- Held by Anne Michaels
- Orbital by Samantha Harvey
- Creation Lake by Rachel Kushner
I was shocked to see that Playground, Headshot and Wandering stars had not made the shortlist, but I decided to try the books that were. Here are my shortlist short reviews:

Creation lake by Rachel Kushner
With musings on Neanderthals and homo erectus, we follow “Sadie Smith”, a “typical” woman in her mid thirties that’s also a secret agent.
This did not read like a thriller or any of the above to me, but more like a diary that was very removed from the story. I felt like I was reading it all in hindsight, so there was no drive or real tension there. I also didn’t get any sense of the environment so it all felt like it was floating in the hypothetical. For me, the most interesting parts were the ones where she talks about the Neanderthals. And to be honest, I did not see the correlation between these fun facts and the rest of the story.
In the end I never really managed to get into the story, because it was told in a way that was hard for me to grasp. Like listening to my mom rambling a neverending story about people I don’t know with no real point. Which is to say, I was bored. ⭐⭐

James by Percival Everett
Huck Finn was my favorite as a child so a reimagined story from the perspective of Jim was certainly a must read for me.
I wish I had reread Huck Finn prior so I could really get into the likeness and the differences, because it’s been so long that I barely remember any details.
My first impression was that it was funny, the kind of funny that comes from switching it up to “play that role” that has been thrust upon you. The ironies and crazy scenarios that follow that are almost slapstick funny – like when Jim is painted to look white so he can be painted to look blackface to blend in with the whites doing blackface. Or when he puts on his “slave dialect”.
There were a few changes made to the story that ruined it a little for me, but to avoid spoiling anything I won’t list them. While I thought the writing was great and immersive, as all of Everetts other books that I’ve read, the changes to a classic book irked me a bit.
But after letting it sit with me for a while, I has been a book that has stayed with me. So I think I liked it more than my first reaction. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Orbital by Samantha Harvey
Six astro- and cosmonauts orbit the world every 90 minutes, completing 16 orbits in a span of 24 hours. We follow along as they reminisce about life on earth while see it from a different perspective. They follow typhooons that ravage while they sit in a position of omnipotence yet being helpless to aid at the same time. It’s a fascinating read that gives a quiet and calm overview of humanity and our planet.
I liked this book way more than I thought I would, or maybe I just liked what it awakened in me. A step back, to see the bigger picture. Lean out just a little bit, the view might be different there. At just over 200 pages, this is a short little gem that’s easy to follow, because there is absolutely no real plot, just musings and wonder. ⭐⭐⭐⭐

The Safekeep by Yael Van Der Wouden
This book runs under the surface, like an underground river. On the surface it’s very calm, and not a lot is going on, but it is rumbling underneath about to arrive. And arrive it does, in a crescendo!
Honestly, I saw the twists coming a mile away, but that’s okay, this is not a thriller type of book that needs to keep it’s secrets. This is a beautifully told book that needed to be shared. And I’m so glad I read it. It’s a slow burn, but when it bursts into flame it is spectacular and impossible to look away from. ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Stone Yard Devotional by Charlotte Wood
An atheist woman enters a convent in Australia to escape the world, and then she spends her days ruminating on her past experiences and chasing mice.
It sounds a little bit like the “pray” part of eat, pray, love, but without the humour. This book is mostly dealing with grief and loss, and mice.
The problem for me is that I can’t find anything driving it forwards. It’s just day after boring day, like a diary that you don’t really need for anyone to read because real life isn’t as interesting as you think it is. I ended up DNFing this so I won’t give it any star rating.

Held by Anne Michaels
Stories in past, present and future is told in vignettes about a soldier during WWI, his childhood, his falling in love, his battles and his return to normal (and miraculous) life.
“From the edge of the North Sea, twenty miles distant, a faint hum reached the stone ear, the acoustic mirror that faced the sea. The measured drone of an aircraft engine twenty miles away. Fifteen precious minutes warning”
In beautiful prose Anne Michaels tells us a story about a very romanticized life. And by all means, I do admire anyone who manages to romanticize ever single little mundane thing. (But it’s a fine line until I roll my eyes at it too.)
“How many countries switch points that had been necessary to bring them together at this table, this country night at the end of summer, under the ancient map of the stars, a map taht had already passed out of existence, yet lumious and clear.”
The quotes can be taken out of anywhere since the story isn’t linear and while I felt it beautifullly told, it slipped out of my hands because there wasn’t enough for me to grab a hold on to. It was chopped up prose that jumps between letters, past, present, future, thought and memory and I didn’t connect to the story. But if you love beautiful prose, it may be enough for you, in some cases, it’s certainly enough for me. ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Who do I think will win?
By my reviews I have to say Held, The Safekeep, Orbital or James, but these are all four books that will stay with me a long time. James was an obvious choice and it’s so easy to like, because we know the story so well. But in the same breath I want to say that it makes it difficult to tell a well known story well from a different perspective, and it truly did that. The Safekeep was a book that sort of snuck up on me. I started the audiobook and I didn’t really like it, but I figured it was the narrator, so I started it over reading the book myself and I enjoyed it so much more. To me it was predictable, but a story worth telling, and I liked how it unfolded. Much like Orbital, I didn’t really understand this book at first, but once I just succumbed to being along for the ride I found it to be a little gem that has stayed with me. Held was written entirely in beautiful prose and while the sentences spoke to me, the story didn’t.
If I’m going to place a bet, my money is on James. It’s a humurous and needed perspective and retelling of a beloved story that is outdated. But it keeps it alive through reinventing it and I find that it’s a much better path than banning or changing the original. (If you don’t know they changed the language of the book some years ago, but that’s a whole other debate!) The Safekeep, is a solid second for me, one I would have loved to see win, if James was not in the running. And Orbital would be my third.
Excited to see who will win!

